-
Once upon a time, Gerry Trudeau was witty, ironic and insightful. Doonesbury was the best political comic strip ever done. These days, however, the strip is simply nasty and hateful. Compare these two strips, the first from Christmas, 1973, during the height of the Watergate scandal:
Note the humanity that Trudeau is able to grant to Richard Nixon, a man who was easy to dislike. Then compare that to the bile oozing from today's Sunday strip regarding Arnold Schwarzenegger, where he suggests Arnold can be summed up as a sex-crazed, power-mad Hitler idolator:
Time for another sabbatical, G.B. Posted by Kevin Murphy at November 23, 2003 01:37 PM | TrackBack
Um ... maybe Trudeau'll grant Ah-nuld some humanity on Christmas Day. I certainly don't think he cut Nixon (or any of his targets since) much slack (nor is that the business he's in).
Posted by: Infospigot at November 23, 2003 11:33 PMI have a fairly complete collection of the books he put out during the period. There is NOTHING that even approaches todays cartoon. Even when he raked the Nixon boys over the coals, he used irony and wit. Feel free to find a Doonesbury in the period 1970-1974 that is as vicious as today's. Say one that calls Nixon a Nazi ....
There's utterly nothing funny about Doonesbury today -- he's replaced the rapier for the club-with-nail-in-it.
Posted by: Kevin Murphy at November 23, 2003 11:59 PMWhen did Trudeau get religion on sexual harrassment? I don't seem to recall it being such a big deal from 1992-2000.
You're right - he's gone from a bright youngster to a cranky old man, bitter and disappointed that the world at large doesn't dance to his tune.
Some people gain wisdom with age; Gerry seems to have lost his.
Posted by: Kevin "fun" Murphy at November 24, 2003 07:48 AMInteresting name.... I guess with 4 million bloggers I shouldn't be surprised.
Anyway, Trudeau did take Clinton to task over Monica, but there it was the civilized irony and such of old. But he apparently has fallen into the Bush-haters camp, and things have become very nasty in the last few years.
If this goes on, the strip is going to drop from a lot of papers -- or at least be moved to the bile & invective section. A sabbatical would seem a good idea if this is the best he can do.
Posted by: Kevin Murphy at November 24, 2003 09:06 AMMy favorite outrage was when Trudeau implied that Schwarzenegger was a rapist.
Can you imagine any cartoonist on the right getting away with saying such things about a Democratic governor?
Posted by: J.P. Carter at November 24, 2003 12:51 PMI doubt anyone could have got away with a comic strip calling Clinton a rapist, despite there being a woman claiming that he raped her.
Posted by: Kevin Murphy at November 24, 2003 02:42 PMI find it interesting that even in the early 70s Trudeau had strips consisting of one drawing with no human figures in it. For some reason I thought Trudeau adopted that shortcut more recently.
Posted by: Bud Norton at November 25, 2003 10:31 AM